[{"id":2712403980,"handle":"frontpage","updated_at":"2026-09-26T23:37:13-04:00","published_at":"2018-01-26T23:47:52-05:00","sort_order":"created-desc","template_suffix":null,"published_scope":"global","title":"All Products","body_html":""},{"id":474260406501,"handle":"all-products","title":"All Products","updated_at":"2026-09-26T23:37:13-04:00","body_html":"","published_at":"2025-06-30T17:47:14-04:00","sort_order":"best-selling","template_suffix":"","disjunctive":false,"rules":[{"column":"variant_inventory","relation":"greater_than","condition":"0"}],"published_scope":"global"},{"id":494365376741,"handle":"best-pins-for-bartending","updated_at":"2026-09-26T23:37:13-04:00","published_at":"2026-01-14T21:09:30-05:00","sort_order":"best-selling","template_suffix":"","published_scope":"global","title":"Best Pins for Bartending","body_html":""},{"id":409713246437,"handle":"best-sellers","title":"Best Sellers","updated_at":"2026-09-26T23:37:13-04:00","body_html":"","published_at":"2023-11-09T15:21:07-05:00","sort_order":"best-selling","template_suffix":"","disjunctive":false,"rules":[{"column":"variant_price","relation":"greater_than","condition":"0"},{"column":"variant_inventory","relation":"greater_than","condition":"0"}],"published_scope":"global"},{"id":521406644453,"handle":"classic-cocktail-sweetheart-pins","updated_at":"2026-09-26T23:37:13-04:00","published_at":"2026-09-26T23:05:49-04:00","sort_order":"most-relevant","template_suffix":null,"published_scope":"global","title":"Classic Cocktail Sweetheart Pins","body_html":null},{"id":57459834957,"handle":"new-releases","updated_at":"2026-09-26T23:37:13-04:00","published_at":"2018-06-08T16:19:36-04:00","sort_order":"manual","template_suffix":"","published_scope":"global","title":"Featured Products","body_html":""},{"id":409713148133,"handle":"new-releases-1","title":"New Arrivals","updated_at":"2026-09-26T23:37:13-04:00","body_html":"","published_at":"2023-11-09T15:18:46-05:00","sort_order":"created-desc","template_suffix":"","disjunctive":false,"rules":[{"column":"variant_inventory","relation":"greater_than","condition":"0"},{"column":"tag","relation":"not_equals","condition":"exclude-new-arrivals"}],"published_scope":"global"},{"id":473925583077,"handle":"pins-1","title":"Pins","updated_at":"2026-09-26T23:37:13-04:00","body_html":"","published_at":"2025-06-23T08:58:31-04:00","sort_order":"created-desc","template_suffix":"","disjunctive":false,"rules":[{"column":"title","relation":"contains","condition":"Pin"},{"column":"variant_inventory","relation":"greater_than","condition":"0"},{"column":"variant_price","relation":"greater_than","condition":"4"},{"column":"tag","relation":"not_equals","condition":"exclude-from-collection"}],"published_scope":"global"},{"id":505062719717,"handle":"restock-collection","updated_at":"2026-09-26T23:37:13-04:00","published_at":"2026-04-03T13:34:05-04:00","sort_order":"best-selling","template_suffix":"","published_scope":"global","title":"Restock Collection","body_html":""},{"id":406165422309,"handle":"sweethearts","updated_at":"2026-09-26T23:37:13-04:00","published_at":"2023-02-03T15:57:28-05:00","sort_order":"best-selling","template_suffix":"","published_scope":"global","title":"Sweethearts","body_html":""},{"id":160259506253,"handle":"valentines-day","updated_at":"2026-09-26T23:37:13-04:00","published_at":"2020-04-01T13:13:15-04:00","sort_order":"alpha-asc","template_suffix":"","published_scope":"global","title":"Valentine's Day","body_html":""}]
["bar accessories","bar culture","bar gift","bartender accessories","bartender gift","bartender merch","bartender pin","Bartender Valentine","bartending","bourbon cocktail","bourbon lover","Candy Heart","classic cocktails","cocktail culture","cocktail enthusiast","cocktail lover","cocktail merch","cocktail pin","Cocktail Valentine","Conversation Heart","drink pin","enamel pin","lapel pin","Mixologist Gift","Mixology","mover and shaker","old fashioned","old fashioned cocktail","old fashioned pin","Sweetheart Candy","Valentine Gift","valentine pin","whiskey cocktail","whiskey lover","whiskey pin"]
Old Fashioned Cocktail Sweethearts Pin
Do you love Old Fashioneds? Do you want everyone to know your love Old Fashioneds? Oh boy, do we have just the pin for you...
In Search of the Ultimate Old Fashioned (link here )
The unequivocal winner of the tasting delivered from the very first sip.
T om Macy, who also took the top spot at our tasting in 2018, builds his Old-Fashioned on two ounces of Wild Turkey 101 rye, a teaspoon of 2:1 Demerara syrup and three dashes of his personalized bitters blend known as Dad’s Bitters—a mix of Angostura, Bitter Truth orange and Bitter Truth Jerry Thomas’ Own Decanter bitters—stirred and strained, then garnished with both lemon and orange twists.
“You can taste both garnishes, but they don’t dominate,” said Morrissey. Perhaps unsurprisingly for a recipe that was the result of more than 40 attempts in the making, Macy’s Old-Fashioned was deemed “dead on” by Cecchini and “far and away the best one,” by Sterling.
2 ounces rye, preferably Wild Turkey 101
1 teaspoon rich Demerara syrup (2:1, demerara:water)
3 dashes Dad's Bitters (see Editor's Note)
Tom Macy’s Old-Fashioned
Garnish: orange and lemon peels
Chloe Frechette for PUNCH DRINK
Product Details:
Age verification
By clicking enter you are verifying that you are old enough to consume alcohol.
